Matthew 10:40-42
40 “Whoever welcomes you welcomes me, and whoever welcomes me welcomes the one who sent me. 41 Whoever welcomes a prophet in the name of a prophet will receive a prophet’s reward; and whoever welcomes a righteous person in the name of a righteous person will receive the reward of the righteous; 42 and whoever gives even a cup of cold water to one of these little ones in the name of a disciple—truly I tell you, none of these will lose their reward.”
Beloved, children of God, Grace, peace, and mercy are yours in the name of Christ. Amen.
And Jesus said to them, “Whoever welcomes you, welcomes me.”
Earlier this month, our denomination got a bit of 15 minutes of fame. One of our very own ELCA pastors and congregations was featured on the first episode of the newest season of Queer Eye. For those of you who don’t know, Queer Eye is a makeover show on Netflix where 5 lifestyle and fashion gurus, also known as The Fab 5, are invited and welcomed into a person’s life for a week-long make over.
In this particular episode, Pastor Noah Hepler has been nominated by his church council for a make-over. He needed a new look and the confidence to go with it.
Much of the episode tends to the material side of Pastor Noah’s life. A closet full of clothes he didn’t feel confident in, and an unkempt parsonage apartment with mold and collapsing drywall. All of which the Fab 5 declared as the physical manifestation of the stress in Noah’s life.
But the heartbeat of the episode isn’t in the material, external make-over, but rather is in the spiritual, internal work going on inside Pastor Noah. Not only is Noah the pastor of a struggling congregation in Fishtown, Pennsylvania, but Noah is also a pastor struggling with his identity as a gay man. Like so many who grew up in the church, Noah was taught that queer people were wrong and probably going to hell. This led to a lifetime of feeling like he didn’t belong, and led to a marriage that he thought could hide in, which inevitably ended in divorce.
Pastor Noah was having a crisis of identity. He was struggling to accept who he was because of the theological abuse he received from his church as child. But he also felt ashamed that he had accepted and welcomed his sexuality earlier on in life, because he carried so much guilt for not being an activist and on the front lines of people years ago leading the church into greater acceptance of the LGBTQ community. He didn’t step up when he thought he should have. And so he had an overwhelming sense of imposter syndrome as a gay pastor in a faith that did so much psychological damage to him and to so many others. And wondered if he really was the right person to lead a church now, even though he finally feels ready to be the leader he’s been called to be. Who am I? Is it too late? Who can I be?
Later on in the episode, Pastor Noah gets this pep-talk from Pastor Megan Rohrer, one of the first openly transgender pastors in the ELCA Lutheran church. She says to him with this urgency in her voice, “Noah, our world needs you right now. And is calling you…(It’s not too late!) And the good news you put out (into the world through your ministry) makes me think there is a place in the church for all those who feel like they don’t fit in.”
Suddenly, Pastor Noah starts to come alive. You can see it in his smile. Pastor Noah tells the story about a young man, in his small congregation, who has been part of their church since childhood. And though everyone who loves him has known he was gay for years, that young man didn’t come out to the church until this year. Pastor Noah, still coming alive, said he was “elated that for (this young person) the one place that won’t tell him anything bad about who he is will be his church.”
As you watch this moment, you can almost see and feel the wrestling of identities within Noah. Who am I? Am I an outsider destined for struggle my whole life? Am I gay man complicit in the suffering of my own people? Did I not come out soon enough? Am I too late to be whom I am called to be? Can I be a pastor ready to shed the cloak of my past and lead into the future of God’s kingdom come near? Who am I?
And then Pastor Megan looks Noah in the eyes, and says, “Noah, would you ever tell that kid in your congregation that he didn’t come out soon enough?” And Pastor Noah said, “No.”
Pastor Megan said, “So why do you tell yourself that, child of God?”
And that was the moment. Child of God, she called him.
The gospel-in-a-nutshell right there on Netflix reality TV.
Suddenly, all those other identities that were fighting for center-stage in his life were moved aside for who he really was. His true and unwavering identity – Child of God. And in that moment, a deep moment of relief washed over Pastor Noah as he was anointed into the silence and tears of being known.
And Jesus said, “Whoever welcomes you, welcomes me.”
Whoever welcomes you, welcome me.
Something about that little three-letter word – you – stood out to me this week. What strikes me is just how piercing it can be if we let it. You. Whoever welcomes you. This week I was reminded of just how weighed down we can get from all the identities we carry with us – such that when we hear a simple word like “You”, our first thought is…which one? Which me are you talking about Jesus? The confident co-worker I am at my job or the crushingly insecure spouse I am at home?
Which me are you talking about Jesus? The guilt-riddened failure of a mother I think I am or the super-fun-loving-I’ll-make-up-for-it-on-the-next-generation Grandma that I try to be.
Which me are you talking about Jesus? The me who projects an image of someone who is keeping up-to-date on all the things, all the monumental shifts that are happens in our world and society right now and doing my part, or the me who is hanging on by his finger-nails and just simply cannot get caught up on laundry.
Whoever welcomes you, welcome me. It’s easy for us, as the church, to take this short gospel reading as a command to go and do something. To go and be hospitable and be welcoming in the world.
And don’t get me wrong – I do think the church is called to that ministry. Jesus is sending his followers out to those who are lost, and sick, and outcast, and to welcome them into the kingdom of God. I just think we forget how hard and risky that is and what it demands of us, when we aren’t always even sure who we are in the kingdom of God.
In this long sending speech, Jesus tells his disciples-soon-to-be-Apostles to go with nothing to their name. No money, no bags for the journey, no extra set of clothes. Jesus asks them to go from house to house, where sometimes they will be greeted kindly and sometimes they won’t. Which means that as followers of Jesus, we will be asked to put ourselves in less-than-comfortable situations. Into places and with people and situations that are unfamiliar to us. At times it will feel like being sheep sent out into the midst of wolves, Jesus says. Meaning that at times, the life you’ve been living will feel under threat.
I can only imagine that some of them would have had an overwhelming sense of imposter syndrome too. Me, Jesus? Really? Who am I to be your apostle? Not only because many of them were common fisherman and tradespeople, not trained to be laborers in the kingdom of God, but also because of their own pasts. Where some of their loyalties and identities used to reside. Because of who they used to be.
You see, one of the things I love about the Gospel of Matthew is that it likes to hide crucial clues inside the mundane. Particularly inside lists of names. At the beginning of this chapter, the author lists the names of Jesus’ apostles. These are the names of Jesus’ Apostles: Simon Peter and Andrew, James, and John, Philip and Bartholomew, and Thomas and Mathew the Tax Collector, and James and Thaddeus, Simon the Cananaean, and Judas Iscariot.
Most of us skim over such lists and move on to the rest of the story, but the gospel of Matthew wants us to be stopped in our tracks. Because this list tells us something about who is included in this group of called apostles, sent out in God’s name. You see hidden within this list is the little detail that Matthew was a tax collector – meaning he used to be an employee and lackey of Rome, the empire. And in the very same breath, the name of Simon the Cananaean is mentioned. “The Cananaean” likely being a title revealing Simon’s participation in a group of zealots ready to overthrow with violence the Roman Empire.
Matthew the Tax Collector and Simon the Cananaean. Apostles of Jesus.
“To find the former Roman (loyalist) Matthew and the revolutionary, anti-Rome Simon together among the disciples is quite striking.”[1] It reminds us that followers of Jesus sent out to minister to a hurting world are not a group of like-minded people with a squeeky-clean history. But rather are a group of people whose own lives have been cluttered and weighed down with complex and competing identities, and those are the very people who also have been called to be bearers of the grace and love of God to a world in turmoil.
And I just don’t think there is anyway they can do that without casting aside all those competing and fragile identities in order to know who they are. Who they really are.
And so maybe this short gospel reading isn’t a command, maybe it’s a blessing. Maybe Jesus ends his call to action not with a command of what we are to do, but with a blessing of who we are. “Whoever welcomes you, welcomes me.”
The you whom I have called blessed. The you whom I have declared the light of the world and the salt of the earth. The you whom God called at the moment of your existence, “This is my beloved child, with whom I am well pleased.”
Whoever welcome you, Child of God, welcomes me.
I imagine that was the moment. When a deep moment of relief washed over these Jesus sends these ill-equipped deer in the head lights apostles that Jesus was sending out into a world that can be both hospitable and hostile. But a children of God, they carry Christ with them. In their very being. For no other reason than that Christ has bound his life up in theirs. Jesus gives them nothing to carry. Nothing but himself. God with us. Knowing and trusting that they too have been gripped by such a grace that saves us from all other false identities that try to lay claim over us, they have empty hands but full hearts, and an identity that is everlasting.
And Jesus said, “Whoever welcomes you, welcomes me.” It’s not too late.
I know we are living in a time when we are living in a time where we are all being asked to look outside of ourselves – how we welcome and care for the stranger, the neighbor, those who are different than us. And that is sacred and critical work that we cannot look away and move on from.
But I also see us living in a time when we are all being asked to look more deeply inside ourselves and our life and at the assumptions and unquestioned privileges we’ve been living with. For many of us, this is the first time in our life when we’ve had to wonder if we will be welcome and safe in the places we go. This is the first time we’ve been asked to follow rules that cramp our style and suffocate our self-image, all for the sake of others. And that is a privilege we have had and taken advantage of for far too long.
It’s a scary thing to really look in the mirror and ask “Who am I? Who am I called to be? Is it too late?” That is what’s being asked of us. And I don’t know if any of us can really do that crucial and spiritual work without knowing that Christ stands beside you when you do.
And Jesus said, “Whoever welcomes you, welcomes me.”
The real you. You, child of God. The you that is beneath the surface of all the identities you’ve gathered up over the years, desperately clinging to hold to and to balance in the grip of just two human hands.
In the midst of a global pandemic, and the call to dismantle racism within our own communities and within our own hearts, in the midst of PRIDE month where we celebrate the upholding of LGBTQ rights that are long overdue but as we continue to witness a prejudice that is still alive in us and in our country, we the Church are called out to be the presence of Christ to others and to receive the presence of Christ in others. And there is simply no way we can step out and up into that hard, and scary, and life-changing work, without first being blessed with the reminder of who and whose we are.
I wonder if you, like Pastor Noah, can finally hear your name called, as you really are. Child of God. Beloved apostle.
These are the names of Jesus’ apostles: Nathan and David, Chuck and Anita, Pam and Ruth, Samuel and Oden, Luke and Izzy, Clara and Karl, Dau and Erik, Anna and Abner, Emmett and Joran, Ellie and Monica, Rachel and Joan, Marilyn and Todd.
That’s twice as many as the Gospel of Matthew lists and I could go on and on and on.
Can you hear your name on that list? It’s not too late. Because your name is on that list.
And so before you go, hear this blessing – whoever welcomes you, welcomes Christ. For you are God’s beloved. Amen.
[1] Thomas G. Long, Matthew, pg. 115.